The myth of Manchester United is the myth of resurrection.

Plenty of clubs have won trophies. But United’s mythology comes from the idea that the club is always being asked to rise from ruin, and that when it does, it does so with youth, drama, arrogance and a slightly unreasonable belief that history is on its side. That it’s inevitable.

The foundational story is of course that of the Busby Babes. Matt Busby built a side around extraordinarily young players at a time when English football was more cautious and hierarchical. Then Munich happened in 1958. Eight players died. The team in a quite literal sense was destroyed. And yet Busby himself survived, rebuilt, and ten years later United became the first English club to win the European Cup. Bobby Charlton, a survivor of Munich, scored twice in the final.

That sequence of youth and bravado, catastrophe or downfall, resurrection or rising from the ashes is what is basically United’s creation myth.

Then came the holy trinity - Best, Law, Charlton. Three completely different archetypes. Charlton was dignity and permanence. Law was predatory intensity. Best was genius, glamour and self-destruction. United stopped being merely a football club and became part of British popular culture. It was charisma, it was aura, and it is a certain penchant for style.

Then came the Ferguson era that turned that mythology into a system. The thing about Fergie is that he understood what United was supposed to feel like. Young players coming through. Wingers attacking full-backs. Games won in the final minutes. A certain disdain for caution. The belief that 1-0 down at Old Trafford with ten minutes left was somehow a disadvantageous position for the opposition!

That is why “Fergie time” became more than a joke. Opponents felt that the clock behaved differently against United. Old Trafford developed a psychological quality. The club’s greatest teams often did not simply beat their opponents. They convinced us that resistance was futile.

There is also a fascinating contradiction at the heart of United. It is perhaps the most commercially successful football institution England ever produced, yet its self-image, I think, is deeply romantic. It is a global superclub whose mythology is built around local boys. A corporate colossus that worships rebels like Cantona and Best. A club associated with immense money that still wants to believe its deepest advantage is courage.

And then there is arrogance which at its best is essential to United. Cantona, Rooney, Ronaldo embodied it. Ferguson institutionalised it. This is also why the post-Fergie period has hurt in a way that ordinary bad seasons do not. The crisis is not merely that United stopped winning enough or winning at all. It is that the club has stopped behaving recognisably like United. Reactive football. Recruitment without coherence. Famous players without a shared idea.

A giant institution unsure of what its own mythology demands.

But paradoxically, that makes the story more interesting. If United had simply continued winning indefinitely after Ferguson, it might eventually have become something closer to a machine. Instead, the club has entered another wilderness. And the United myth has always needed a wilderness.

Newton Heath nearly went bankrupt before becoming Manchester United. Munich nearly destroyed the team before 1968. United were relegated in 1974. Ferguson came close to being dismissed before creating a dynasty. The European Cup final in 1999 was almost lost. The 2008 final came down to a penalty hitting a post.

Again and again, United’s history has had this structure. Greatness followed by catastrophe and disbelief but always, always resurrection.

But that is the real myth. And it explains something about being a United supporter today. We aren’t merely waiting for the club to become competent again. We are waiting for the next chapter that feels worthy of everything before it. Because the most intoxicating promise in Manchester United’s history has never been that the club will always be great.

It is that United comes back.